Lion In The Forest

Animals Eat Other Animals . . . Why Can't I?

May 06, 2018

One of the first things people think of when approached about Veganism is the fact that animals eat other animals.  This case is often used in support of the concept that eating animals is a moral act that humans partake in, but does this hold up as morally and logically consistent?  Let’s take a look -

Appeal To Nature

The premise of this argument is an Appeal to Nature Fallacy; the idea that because something is considered natural, it is therefore valid, justified, good, or ideal.  There are many things in nature that we deem as good; the sun, water, oxygen, family units, mutualism, etc.  But there are countless things in nature that we deem as bad; viruses, murder, xenophobia, theft, etc.  People have a tendency to point to lions specifically in this case, but should we accept lions’ behavioral patterns as guidelines for human morality?  Absolutely not.  Lions have already been documented partaking in activities that we deem as undoubtedly unethical, such as rape and the killing of their own offspring (watch videos of it and it’ll make your stomach churn.)  That is why this argument is fallacious, we cannot appeal to nature as being a moral baseline unless we accept everything that occurs in nature as being morally just. 

Necessity

Lions and other obligate carnivores also have to eat animals to survive.  It is completely necessary.  The opposite is true for humans.  Not only are humans able to survive & thrive on a plant-based diet (the countless health benefits are just a bonus), but we now live in a time where plant-based options are abundant.  We have a choice and they don’t.  This means that consuming animals and their byproducts is now an unnecessary act of violence.  In the modern world, eating animals is just as unnecessary as beating a cat or dog. 

Moral Agency

Additionally, humans have moral agency and animals don’t.  We can make judgements based on notions of right and wrong, and can be held accountable for those judgements.  Animals cannot be held accountable in this manner. 

Once it is recognized that we can’t justify needlessly killing animals for food just because other animals do so, people often revert to other Appeal to Nature Fallacies.  These include perceived adaptations such as ‘canines’ and ‘enzymes,’ concepts such as a food chain or ‘the circle of life,’ and the belief that humans are naturally omnivorous.  These appeals fail as well of course, but we’ll address them in a later post.

Conclusion

While people do point to animals’ eating habits when approached by veganism, they generally don’t consider mirroring animals' other habits.  It seems as though most people recognize we live in a modern, contemporary world, not fit for all primitive or “natural” behavior.  It may be difficult to connect the dots to what we eat because Carnism is the dominant ideology within most cultures.



Leave a comment


Also in News

Drake Performing Live
Drake Ditches Meat . . . Could he be vegan?

March 17, 2018

Canadian rapper Drake confirmed that he is at least vegetarian on live gaming platform Twitch this week.  He got together with Twitch personality Tyler 'Ninja' Belvins to competitively game in one of the platform's most-watched livestreams.  He and Tyler were discussing food when the controversial questions was asked, "Does pineapple belong on pizza?"

Read More

Donatella Says Versace is Going Fur-Free
Donatella Says Versace is Going Fur-Free

March 14, 2018

Donatella Versace has followed in the footsteps of other fashion giants such as Gucci and Furla by announcing that Versace will be going fur-free.  The fashion magnate expressed her concern regarding fur in an interview with Luke Leitch of The Economist's 1843 Magazine, stating "Fur? I am out of that. I don’t want to kill animals to make fashion. It doesn’t feel right."

Read More

Vegan Girl Scout Cookies
Which Girl Scout Cookies Are Vegan?

February 25, 2018

It's that time of year again!  The cookies everyone loves from their childhood are back, but which of them are vegan?  This all depends on where you live, and which baker (either ABC Bakers or Little Brownie Bakers) is associated with that area.  Here is a rough map of which area supplies what -
Now let's take a look into which of them are vegan!

Read More